Break the Rules, But Stick to Your Principles

About 2,000 years ago, a young carpenter from Nazareth cured a blind man, allowing him to see for the first time in his life. By all rights, this feat should have made Him a hero in the eyes of any who had witnessed or heard about it.
One problem: He decided to perform this miracle on the Sabbath, a day of rest according to church law. As a result, He was vilified as a sinner by church leaders for performing work on the Sabbath day. But shouldn’t He have been praised for restoring the man’s sight?
Throughout the ages, people have spent a lot of time trying to formulate rules. Rules of behaviour, rules of government, rules of business, etc. And the reason behind the effort is noble enough: to try to make things clearer and simpler to understand.
However, the problem with rules is that they don’t always stand the test of time and they can be construed in many ways to serve different purposes. And when two people disagree on the interpretation of a rule, the inevitable result is more rules to clear up the situation.
So is life really simpler with more rules?
Consider the Pharisees mentioned earlier. According to the rules at the time, their actions were totally justified. But even though the rules of the church have changed over time, the principle used by Jesus (always try to help those in need) is as relevant and easy to interpret today as it was two millennia ago.
And that’s the real difference between rules and principles. Rules are designed to give specific answers to specific questions. When new situations arise that don’t fall into the current set of rules, the only choice is to create more rules.
Principles, on the other hand, give people general guidance on how to think about problems. They can even be applied to new scenarios that haven’t yet arisen.
From a business point of view, the inherent flexibility in being principles-based can be a huge advantage over rules-based competitors. And nowhere is that more true than in the supply chain area of the organization.
So, what are the characteristics of principles-based organizations?
From a People point of view, principles-based organizations spend far more time educating than training. Training is about showing people how to perform specific tasks. Education is about giving people a general frame of reference to solve problems themselves. Over time, a well educated person will significantly outperform a well trained person in virtually any discipline – including supply chain management.
From a Process point of view, principles-based organizations don’t analyze things to death or count on “the facts” to tell them how to make decisions. Did you need analysis or facts to determine that Jesus’ decision to cure the blind man was the right one, regardless of the rules? Business decisions are no different. More often than not, the right thing to do is obvious – so do it.
From a System point of view, principles-based organizations take a simpler approach. Systems are designed and built to aid people’s thinking, not replace it. A highly complex system with a trillion lines of code to manage the supply chain is a sure sign that an organization is putting its faith in rules, not principles.
Remember, rules are meant to be broken, but principles last forever.

